OC 3/1: Jan 1912-Mar 1912 - Otto Vrieslander: lesson: Thursday January 18, 1912
18. Vrieslander † : Anfang des 3-stimm. Satzes noch einmal Stufen, Stimmführung Orchester-Scizze zu „ernste Gesänge“ von Brahms. 1 [Das vocale Element Hindernis für Entwicklung der Länge, daher auch der Stufen; daher haftet Chorälen, Mottetten in erster Linie {6} Stimmführungscharakter an. Im Instrumentalen kehrt dieselbe Erscheinung in den ganz kleinen Formen wieder; vgl. z.B. Brahms Walzer Gismoll u. manche Schubert’sche.] © Transcription Robert Kosovsky, 2007 |
[January] 18, [1912] Vrieslander † : Start of three-voice counterpoint; once again scale-degrees, voice-leading. Orchestral sketch for the “Four Serious Songs“ by Brahms. 1 [The vocal element [as] impediment for development of long spans, hence also of scale-degrees; that’s why {6} voice-leading character [as in these songs] clings mostly to chorales and motets. In instrumental music this same phenomenon occurs in the very small forms; cf. e.g. Brahms Gě minor Waltz and in much of Schubert’s music.] © Translation Ian Bent, 2021 |
18. Vrieslander † : Anfang des 3-stimm. Satzes noch einmal Stufen, Stimmführung Orchester-Scizze zu „ernste Gesänge“ von Brahms. 1 [Das vocale Element Hindernis für Entwicklung der Länge, daher auch der Stufen; daher haftet Chorälen, Mottetten in erster Linie {6} Stimmführungscharakter an. Im Instrumentalen kehrt dieselbe Erscheinung in den ganz kleinen Formen wieder; vgl. z.B. Brahms Walzer Gismoll u. manche Schubert’sche.] © Transcription Robert Kosovsky, 2007 |
[January] 18, [1912] Vrieslander † : Start of three-voice counterpoint; once again scale-degrees, voice-leading. Orchestral sketch for the “Four Serious Songs“ by Brahms. 1 [The vocal element [as] impediment for development of long spans, hence also of scale-degrees; that’s why {6} voice-leading character [as in these songs] clings mostly to chorales and motets. In instrumental music this same phenomenon occurs in the very small forms; cf. e.g. Brahms Gě minor Waltz and in much of Schubert’s music.] © Translation Ian Bent, 2021 |
Footnotes1 Brahms wrote his “Four Serious Songs” for bass voice and piano; he did not himself produce an orchestrated version. Reference here may perhaps be to a sketch that Vrieslander has brought for Schenker's inspection. |
|
Format† Double underlined |